Awards/Recognition

MONTCLAIR THEATRE NIGHT FOXY AWARDS
  • 2026- "High Superior Scoring Production" Peter Pan and Wendy: A New Old Adventure
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement in Lighting Design for a Play" - Shawn McGovern Peter Pan and Wendy: A New Old Adventure (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement by a Student Sound Designer in a Play" - Azure Meares Peter Pan and Wendy: A New Old Adventure (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement in Stage Combat in a Play" Peter Pan and Wendy: A New Old Adventure (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement by a Dance Ensemble in a Play" Peter Pan and Wendy: A New Old Adventure (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement in Choreography in a Play" - Jessica Teehan Peter Pan and Wendy: A New Old Adventure (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Performance by a Leading Actor" - Judah Nabandian as Peter Peter Pan and Wendy: A New Old Adventure (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Performance by a Featured Ensemble Actress" - Madelyn Stanley as Shadow Peter Pan and Wendy: A New Old Adventure (Nomination)
  • 2026- "High Superior Scoring Production" Shrek the Musical
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement in Scenic Design for a Musical"- Stephen Menard Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement by a Student Lighting Technician for a Musical"- Riley Holmes Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement by a Student Sound Designer in a Musical"- Azure Meares Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement by a Musical Director" -Amy Flynn Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement in Direction of a Musical" -John Stephan Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Performance by a Featured Ensemble Actress" -Sonya Tereshko as Pinocchio Shrek the Musical (WINNER!)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Performance by a Supporting Actor" - James Conner as Donkey Shrek the Musical (WINNER!)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Performance by a Supporting Actor" -Zac Buono as Lord Farquaad Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Performance by a Leading Actor" - Presley Terch as Shrek Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Performance by a Leading Actress" - Annabelle Corigliano as Fiona Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement by a Musical Ensemble" Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Achievement by an Acting Ensemble in a Established Production of a Musical" Shrek the Musical (WINNER!)
  • 2026- "Outstanding Production of a Established Production of a Musical" Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "High Superior Scoring Production" Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition
  • 2025- "Outstanding Achievement in Lighting Design for a Play"- Shawn McGovern Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (WINNER!)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Achievement in Scenic Design for a Play"- Stephen Menard Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Achievement in New Media/Special Effects in a Play"- Dennis Lee Bush Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Achievement by a Dance/Movement Ensemble in a Play" Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (WINNER!)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Achievement in Choreography/Movement in a Play"- Jessica Kelleher Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Achievement by an Actor in a Fantasy/Fable Play"- Presley Terch as Harry Potter Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Acting Ensemble in a Fantasy/Fable Play" Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Production of a Fantasy/Fable Play" Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Achievement in Direction of a Play"- John Stephan Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: High School Edition (Nomination)
  • 2024- "High Superior Scoring Production" She Kills Monsters 
  • 2024- "Outstanding Achievement in Lighting Design for a Play" She Kills Monsters-Shawn McGovern (Nomination)
  • 2024- "Outstanding Achievement in New Media/Special Effects" She Kills Monsters-Lainey Palmer (Nomination)
  • 2024- "Outstanding Achievement in Stage Combat" She Kills Monsters-Terry McIntyre (Nomination)
  • 2024- "Outstanding Achievement by a Dance Ensemble in a Play" She Kills Monsters (WINNER!)
  • 2024- "Outstanding Achievement in Choreography/Movement in a Play" She Kills Monsters-Jessica Kelleher (Nomination)
  • 2024- "Outstanding Achievement by an Actor in a Sci-Fi/Fantasy Play" She Kills Monsters-John Ecker as Chuck (Nomination)
  • 2024- "Outstanding Achievement by an Actress in a Sci-Fi/Fantasy Play" She Kills Monsters-Violet Merrigan as Tilly (Nomination)
  • 2024- "Outstanding Production of a Sci-Fi/Fantasy Play" She Kills Monsters (Nomination)

BERGENPAC HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL AWARDS
  • "Best Ensemble" Bye Bye Birdie (Nomination)​
  • "Best Actor in a Male-Identified Leading Role"- Presley Terch as Albert Peterson Bye Bye Birdie (Nomination)
  • "Best Actor in a Female-Identified Supporting Role"- Constance Fanslau as Mae Peterson Bye Bye Birdie (WINNER!)
  • "Best Ensemble Member"- Sonya Tereshko as Ursula Merkle Bye Bye Birdie (Nomination)
  • "Best Costume Design"- Tina Heinz & Tina's Productions Bye Bye Birdie (Nomination)
  • "Best Sound Design"- Azure Meares & Joy Umeh Bye Bye Birdie (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Special Feature"- Dragon, Horse, and Gingy Shrek the Musical (Nomination) 
  • 2025- "Best Lighting Design"- Shawn McGovern Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Best Sound Design"- Sophia Meares & Joy Umeh Shrek the Musical (WINNER!)
  • 2025- "Best Hair & Make-Up Design- John Rattacasa Shrek the Musical (WINNER!)
  • 2025- "Best Costume Design"- Tina Heinz & Tina's Productions Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Best Orchestra"-Casey Corigliano Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Best Actor in a Female-Identified Feature Role"- Savannah Cox as Dragon Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Best Actor in a Male-Identified Supporting Role" - Sonya Tereshko as Pinocchio Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Best Actor in a Male-Identified Supporting Role"- Zachary Buono as Lord Farquaad Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Best Actor in a Male-Identified Leading Role"- Presley Terch as Shrek Shrek the Musical  (WINNER!)
  • 2025- "Best Actor in a Female-Identified Leading Role"- Annabelle Corigliano as Fiona Shrek the Musical  (WINNER!)​
  • 2025- "Best Musical Direction"- Amy Flynn Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Best Direction"- John Stephan Shrek the Musical (Nomination)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Overall Musical" Shrek the Musical (Nomination)​​
​
PAPER MILL PLAYHOUSE RISING STAR AWARDS
  • 2025- "Outstanding  Performance by a Featured Ensemble Group"- Duloc Dancers Shrek the Musical (Honorable Mention)
  • 2025- "Outstanding Costuming Achievement" Shrek the Musical (Honorable Mention)
  • 2024- "Outstanding Lighting Achievement" The Prom: School Edition (Honorable Mention)

Theatre Pin

The Addams Family Musical (2027)
TBD
TBD
TBD
​TBD

Peter Pan and Wendy ​(2025)
Madelyn Stanley
Judah Nalbandian
​Constance Fanslau
Alice by Heart ​(2026)
TBD
TBD
TBD

​
Shrek the Musical ​(2025)
Presley Terch
Alicia Fallon
Sonya Tereshko
Anthony Coia
Bye Bye Birdie ​(2026)
Maggie Taylor
Michael Ilagan
Aylani Miller
Lyla Messick

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child ​(2024)
James Noonan
Haylie Strafella
​Ashley Coia

Theatre Banquet Awards

Thespian of the Year
2027: TBA
2026: Haylie Strafella

​Most Improved
2027: TBA
​2026: ​Lyla Messick​
Stage Crew Member of the Year
2027: TBA
​2026: ​Andrew DiMeo​

​Un-Sung Hero
2027: TBA
​2026: ​Elijah Colon​
Rookie of the Year
2027: TBA
​2026: ​Michael Ilagan​

​Director's Choice
2027: TBA
​2026: ​Mrs. Teehan​